Peterborough - England
Graham Waite

Graham Waite

Nov 18, 2026

0 Comments
Fake-Away Challenge: What A Homemade Tikka Masala For Four Really Costs
Chicken tikka masala, pilau rice and naan on an ordinary hob, with the supermarket bill and the cost of what actually goes in the pot.
Tikka masala with naan and rice. Illustrative photo, not Laura’s dish. Photo by Jack Baghel on Pexels

In October we asked Laura  whether a homemade Indian fakeaway could beat a £40 takeaway.

 

This is the cooking and shopping half of the answer: the meal, and what it costs to put on the table.

 

One caution first.

 

The £40 in that challenge was an illustration, not a quote from a real takeaway, and we have not priced a comparable takeaway order.

 

So this article does not claim the homemade version “beats” anything.

 

It gives you a recipe and an honest breakdown of the bill.

 

Serves 4. Beginner-friendly. Ordinary saucepan or frying pan; no Thermomix required (although Laura uses her Thermonix)

 

Ingredients

 

Chicken

 

  • 600g boneless, skinless chicken thighs, diced
  • 100g natural yoghurt
  • 1 tsp paprika
  • 1 tsp garam masala
  • ½ tsp ground cumin
  • ½ tsp salt
  • 1 tbsp oil
  •  

Sauce

 

  • 1 onion, chopped
  • 1 tbsp oil
  • 2 tsp ginger-garlic paste
  • 2 tbsp tomato purée
  • 400g tin chopped tomatoes
  • 2 tsp garam masala
  • 1 tsp paprika
  • ½ tsp turmeric
  • 100ml double cream
  • Up to 100ml water
  • Salt, and 1 tsp sugar if you like
  •  

To serve

 

  • Two 250g microwave pilau rice packs
  • Four ready-made naan
  •  

Allergens: this recipe contains milk (yoghurt and cream). Naan usually contains wheat (gluten) and may contain milk, so check the labels on the naan, rice, paste and spices you buy.

 

Method

 

  1. Coat the diced chicken with the yoghurt, paprika, garam masala, cumin and salt. Refrigerate for up to 30 minutes if you have time.
  2. Brown the chicken in batches in the oil for 3 to 4 minutes, then set it aside on a clean plate. It is not fully cooked at this stage.
  3. Soften the chopped onion in the oil for 6 to 8 minutes. Stir in the ginger-garlic paste and dry spices for 30 seconds, then the tomato purée for a minute.
  4. Add the chopped tomatoes and simmer for 8 to 10 minutes, adding water if needed. Blend carefully if you prefer a smooth sauce.
  5. Return the chicken and its juices to the pan and simmer for around 10 to 15 minutes, until the centre of the thickest pieces reaches at least 75°C. Lower the heat, stir in the cream and season.
  6. Heat the rice and naan according to their packs and serve.

 

Kitchen shortcuts

 

Shop-bought naan, microwave pilau rice and ready-made ginger-garlic paste keep the effort down. Check packaged ingredients for allergens.

 

The real cost challenge

 

These figures are illustrative estimates based on ASDA online prices recorded on 6 November 2026.

 

They are not a till receipt, prices change, and spice weights are our estimates rather than weighed measurements. Check current prices before you shop.

 

1. The shopping basket: £19.07. This is what the 14 lines cost at the checkout, buying whole packs. It excludes salt, the optional sugar, delivery and any optional coriander.

 

  • Chicken thighs 600g: £4.38
  • Natural yoghurt 500g: £1.15
  • Chopped tomatoes 400g: £0.47
  • Tomato purée 200g: £0.70
  • Double cream 300ml: £1.70
  • Microwave pilau rice 250g, two packs: £1.40
  • Naan, two 2-packs: £1.60
  • Brown onions 1kg: £0.98
  • Vegetable oil 1 litre: £1.55
  • Ginger-garlic paste 210g: £1.38
  • Garam masala, paprika, ground cumin and turmeric, 100g each at £0.94: £3.76
  •  

2. The ingredients actually used: approximately £9.18, or £2.30 per person.

 

This is the estimated cost of the ingredients that actually go into the meal, rather than the full packs bought at the supermarket.

 

The chicken, tomatoes, rice and naan are used in full. For ingredients such as cream and spices, we've calculated the approximate quantities used.

 

So the shopping basket comes to approximately £19.07 if you're starting with an empty cupboard, but around £9.18 of those ingredients goes into the meal itself.

 

3. What is left: about £9.89 of purchased ingredients. That is the difference between the basket and the amount used. It is not cash back and it is not a saving.

 

Some of it, such as cream and yoghurt, can spoil if you do not use it in time, and the spices only pay off if you cook with them again.

 

So the meal costs about £19.07 to buy from an empty cupboard, but only about £9.18 of that ends up in the pot.

 

Next in the series is a chicken korma that puts some of the leftovers back to work.

 

Food safety

 

  • Keep raw chicken away from ready-to-eat food and wash your hands, board and knife after handling it.
  •  
  • Check that the centre of the thickest pieces of chicken has reached at least 75°C. GOV.UK’s food hygiene guidance gives 70°C for two minutes as the standard, and lists 75°C for 30 seconds as equivalent.
  •  
  • Follow the pack instructions for the rice and naan.
  •  
  • Cool leftovers quickly. Food Standards Scotland advises not leaving cooked food at room temperature for longer than one to two hours and eating leftovers within two days.
  •  
  • Rice needs particular care: cool it quickly, refrigerate it promptly and reheat it only once, until steaming hot all the way through.
  •  

About the Fake-Away Challenge

 

The challenge is being taken on by Laura, who runs the Instagram account Thermomix With Laura and uses a Thermomix in her own kitchen.

 

This version is written for an ordinary hob, so you do not need one.

0 Comments

Join the conversation

Be the first to comment

Share your thoughts above.

Taste Trail - Peterborough


Peterborough Taste Trail Peterborough Taste Trail is a city-wide guide to eating, drinking and going out. Each issue features independent cafés, restaurants, pubs, live music, theatre and real events happening across the city. No filler. No generic listings. Just venues and nights actually worth your time. From midweek lunches to full weekend circuits, Taste Trail helps you plan better nights out — whether it’s date night, girls’ night, live music, late drinks or something different. Published regularly and built for people who want more than “where shall we go?”

© 2026 Taste Trail - Peterborough.